Reviewed by Tony Perez, Owner & President of Sagamore Fence & Deck
The gate drags on the concrete. One section leans a little more after every storm. A few boards have split, and you can see into the neighbor’s yard where you couldn’t last spring. You don’t want to pay for a whole new fence if a repair will do, but you don’t want to keep paying for repairs on a fence that’s finished either.
Repairing or replacing a fence you share with a neighbor? Read who owns the fence and who pays, summarized from Texas A&M AgriLife Extension.
That’s the call we help homeowners make every week. Since 2013, Sagamore Fence & Deck has repaired and replaced fences across Central Texas, including plenty we didn’t build. Here’s how to tell which one your fence needs.
Start With the Posts
Boards and pickets are easy to replace. Posts are the structure. If the posts are solid and set deep enough for your ground, most problems above them can be repaired. If posts are rotted at the base, loose in the ground, or leaning along several runs, the fence is losing its frame, and replacement is usually the better value.
In Central Texas, ground is often the reason posts fail. West of I-35, shallow limestone makes it tempting to set posts short. East of I-35, Blackland clay swells after rain and shrinks in drought, and every cycle works shallow posts loose.

When a Repair Makes Sense
- A few broken or loose boards or pickets
- One or two leaning or broken posts
- A gate that sags, drags or won’t latch
- Storm or impact damage limited to one section
- A fence that’s fairly new, with the rest still straight and solid
Most of our fence repair jobs run $450–$2,100. See how our fence repair in Georgetown and Central Texas works, or fence repair in Austin if you’re in the city.
When Replacement Is the Better Value
- Posts leaning or rotted along several runs, not just one
- Rot at the base of the boards in more than one place
- You’ve paid for repairs more than once in the last couple of years
- More than about a third of the fence needs work at once
- The fence no longer fits your needs: more privacy, a pet that jumps, a new pool, or an HOA rule change
When a third or more of a fence needs work, you’re close to replacement territory anyway. In Georgetown, that’s also about where a permit comes in: minor repairs that replace up to about one-third of a fence generally don’t need one, but larger work usually does.
What Each Typically Costs
| Option | Typical Sagamore project total |
|---|---|
| Fence repair | $450–$2,100 |
| New wood privacy fence | $2,400–$10,000 |
| New ornamental iron fence | $1,800–$7,800 |
These totals come from our recent Austin-area jobs (2024–2026); some projects come in below or above them. For what drives a replacement price, read our fence replacement cost guide for Georgetown.
A Five-Minute Self-Check
- Push test. Push the top of the fence at each post. A little give is normal; a post that rocks in the ground is not.
- Look at the base. Dark, soft wood where the boards meet the ground or the posts meet the concrete means rot.
- Count the problems. Two or three trouble spots point to a repair. Trouble on every run points to replacement.
- Check the gate. A sagging gate is often a hinge-post problem, and it’s one of the most common repairs we make.
- Note the age. A cedar fence typically lasts 12 to 20 years with care. Read how long a wood fence lasts.
How We Help You Decide
We inspect the posts and frame before we recommend anything, then tell you plainly which way we’d go and why. If a repair will buy you good years, that’s what we’ll quote. If the fence is finished, we’ll show you what a new fence installation would look like instead.
- Built Right. Posts, footings and framing planned for Central Texas ground and weather, and installed by our own fully insured crew.
- Priced Fair. One written quote with the materials and scope spelled out. Have a comparable written quote from an established, reputable fence company? Show us, and we’ll match it on the same materials and scope. Handyman and side-job quotes don’t qualify.
- Planned Well. Permits, HOA paperwork, layout and timeline are settled before we build, so build day has no surprises.
- Trust Earned. A 1-year warranty on labor and workmanship, the manufacturer’s warranties on materials, and a local team at 6550 FM 1105 in Georgetown that’s still here after the job.
Repair vs. Replacement FAQs
Is it cheaper to repair or replace a fence?
A repair almost always costs less today. Most of our repair jobs run $450–$2,100, while a new wood privacy fence typically runs $2,400–$10,000. Replacement becomes the better value when posts are failing along several runs or repairs keep coming back.
How old is too old to repair a wood fence?
There’s no single cutoff. A well-built cedar fence typically lasts 12 to 20 years with regular care. Past that, or when rot reaches the posts, replacement is often the better value. We look at the posts first.
Can you repair a fence you didn’t build?
Yes. We repair wood, iron, chain link and other fences we didn’t build. If the fence isn’t worth repairing, we’ll tell you why.
Do I need a permit to repair a fence in Georgetown?
Minor repairs that replace up to about one-third of a fence generally don’t need a permit in Georgetown. Larger replacements usually do, and we handle that paperwork for you.
Not Sure Which One You Need?
Send us a few photos or book a free on-site estimate, and we’ll give you an honest recommendation. Call 512-337-3714 (Mon–Fri, 8:00 AM–4:30 PM), request a free estimate or try our instant quote tool for a ballpark in minutes.